What Last Saturday’s Communications Outage Means

It took a while to determine exactly what happened in western Nevada County last weekend on Saturday evening when all communications, essentially, went down. All DSL, AT&T phone and cell service, and Verizon cell service disappeared just as many of us sat down for dinner and continued through early Sunday morning. With no phone service, that meant even dial-up Internet service was unavailable, as well as access to 911. Lucky those who had phone service with Comcast or DigitalPath, and yes even HughesNet or WildBlue Internet access.

So what did take place? Apparently a telephone pole (although technically they are PG&E poles in northern California) went down along Hwy 49 near Lime Kiln Rd and fell across the road. That pole most likely held a PG&E line plus an AT&T line of some sort. From our sources, an officer gave permission to cut the lines in order to clear the roadway for traffic. This was without understanding of what that AT&T line connected.

It is known that the only wired connectivity to the greater Internet and telephony network here is via AT&T and Comcast fiber optic cable. This is called backhaul. It is why no other provider can offer Internet service locally without an enormous cost for connectivity. It was assumed that the fiber optic cable that brings AT&T’s backhaul into western Nevada County was safely underground. It was also assumed that there would be a redundant fiber optic connection from another geographic direction for redundancy in case this very sort of loss of connectivity occurred.

Those assumptions were wrong on both fronts. We conferred with another rural provider and found out that, typically, AT&T brings one fiber optic cable into a rural area, which may have many strands of fiber optics contained within it. However, more often than not, for cost purposes, it is strung along the PG&E poles rather than buried alongside the highway. There is no redundant back up. In western Nevada County, it is also most likely the sole point of connectivity to the world beyond for cell phones. And it became clear, that Verizon uses AT&T’s backhaul here for their cellular service.

On that night for about eight hours, cash registers didn’t work, 911 wasn’t available, ATMs were down, and security cameras plus monitoring services were unable to transmit. And never mind watching movies on Netflix, using Skype, listening to music on Spotify, visiting with friends on Facebook, or online gaming that night. Imagine if it were a real emergency. Not only is broadband — now defined as 6 Mbps down / 1.5 Mbps up — scarcely available here, but we now know we are tethered to the world by only one strand.

Rural America and Nevada County deserves and requires much better than this.

Luckily, the future does look bright for alternate and reliable solutions. Especially in rural California, as a real revolution is happening across the country. In the next few months, we’ll be posting information on how “what’s next” will be coming much sooner than we could have imagined. Stay tuned and, hopefully, stay connected.

Related Posts:

  • No Related Posts

Google’s Kansas City 1Gig Project is Delayed

It appears that Google is experiencing the same pushback that many non-telco Internet Service Providers hit up against when attempting to install new state-of-the-art fiber optic networks. The obstacles are often in place to give favor to the incumbents. Incumbents who are satisfied making profits off of old and horribly outdated copper and cable networks. Google’s situation is detailed in a recent Kansas City Star article. Google chose Kansas City, Kansas as they were assured a rapid deployment. It appears they are faring somewhat better on the Kansas City, Missouri side of the river. It remains to be seen if an aggressive build out schedule can still be accomplished in Kansas City. An overview on how AT&T stifled progress in the 20th century can be read in Tim Wu’s “The Master Switch“, an excellent fast-paced “who done it” style read on media and infrastructure monoliths in the United States.

Currently, the California Public Utilities Commission (PUC) is revising its requirements for access to the California Advanced Services Fund (CASF), which provides monies for broadband deployment in unserved and underserved areas in the state. One of the requirements for funding, waived during the availability of American Recovery and Reinvestment Act funds for broadband, is that an applicant needs to be an Incumbent Local Exchange Carrier (ILEC) or a Competitive Local Exchange Carrier (CLEC) in order to apply. AT&T is the ILEC in western Nevada County, so the application process for that status is essentially vetted by AT&T, a process they draw out as long as they can. Luckily, the other revisions in the CASF guidelines actually favor funding for projects in rural California. A good thing because the PUC has actually, and this is truly astonishing, had a difficult time doling out the funds over the past five years.

The future is fiber optics. Google knows it. Rural telephone companies and publicly owned utility companies are stepping up across rural America and deploying fiber to the home networks. Projects have or are in the process of being built in places such as Sunriver, Oregon; New Braunfels, Texas; and  Lafayette, Louisiana. The shining example is the deployment of fiber to the home in Chattanooga, Tennessee, where the local electricity utility built a fiber network for their new Smart Grid technology, only to be sued three times by the local cable operator when they announced that the same fiber deployed to each home would be used for ultra high-speed Internet access.

Aside from Verizon’s roll out of FIOS in select urban markets, which came to a screeching halt in 2011, rural American is taking the lead when it comes to fiber optic networks. Western Nevada County is primed for this type of connectivity. Are we ready to participate? And what will it take? … to be continued …

Related Posts:

  • No Related Posts

Spiral Internet featured in Broadband Blindness

Earlier this year, Sacramento filmmaker Rob Osborn, came to Nevada City to tape part of a proposed online series about broadband Internet access in northern California. The three part 25-minute video, titled “Broadband Blindness“, was posted today for viewing. John Paul, co-owner of Spiral Internet, was interviewed for the series, and is featured in all three parts. Portions of the 95959google video, produced by Silver Avenue Pictures are included in part 3 of the series.

Related Posts:

  • No Related Posts